Good news. If gasket was weeping you would typically see a cylinder with a drop of 10 or 20 lbs or more. I would NOT pull head at this point. Others mentioned a few things to check, like thermostats. Has impeller been changed recently? Is engine on a jack plate?
Water pressure gauge is a must have on 2 strokes. I suggest you put that near top of the list of things to do. It will be very helpful as you continue to work thru this issue you have.

